Free Web Hosting by Netfirms
Web Hosting by Netfirms | Free Domain Names by Netfirms

Back

Reviews: IBM Microdrive

Home

linux.gif (1876 bytes)

 
IBM 340MB & 1GB Compact Flash Type II Micro Drive
Reviewed By, Bill Beehner (SimplyHPC Staff)
The Specifics...
IBM Corporation
http://www.ibm.com
CF Type II Storage Solution

Price as Reviewed:  $279.00 (340mb)

What you're going to like:
Lightweight with excellent storage ability, excellent potential
 
What you're not going to like:
Storage Card name changes, drive spin down causes applications to hang/lag, not rugged at all (easy does it during transportation).

 

 

 

 

There are issues, but do yourself a favor and pick one up.

This is a well needed addition for any PDA in general that supports the Type II Compact Flash Form Factor, or has an available PCMCIA Slot.

IBM has included the PCMCIA Adapter, critical for devices such as Laptops and the Jornada 720 Handheld PC.  I have used this drive in my laptop, my digital camera, my iPAQ and my Jornada 720.

While the power consumption is arguable, the performace is questionable.  No doubt this is one hell of a drive, and I hope to see the storage sizes increase thie year.  I do however, have a problem with the lag. Most contributing to the lag, is the spinning down of the drives after data access. 

Applications that are stored on the drive are 'hesitant' to load.   Mp3's sometimes stop playing or skip (this could also be due to Media Player) while being accessed/played..  Pocket PC and H/PC 2000 systems both experience problems accessing applications from time to time that are stored on the Microdrive after a soft reset.

This drive is best geared towards those storing and accessing   larger databases, ebooks, tech doc's, etc.  I don't recommend this drive for Mp3 playback, as I have experienced problems every single time during playback (on both the iPAQ and Jornada 720). This drive is also excellent for storing large photo collections, surpassed by none.

One final issue I did notice, is that you cannot install (or at least in my experience) an application such as AvantGO to the Microdrive.  It causes all sorts of chaos when you bring your system back up, and initially sync (this applies to both the iPAQ and Jornada 720)

UPDATE 10.2.01
One problem that can get very annoying, is when inserting and removing the Micro Drive from within the Jornada 720, and the Storage Card name change.  This happens sometimes when you have the Micro Drive in use with a Compact Flash Card simultaneously in the 720.  If you have a CF Card in the slot of the 720, and you insert the Microdrive into the PCMCIA Slot, many times the system will assign new names to the cards. This causes a problem if say for example you have a dozen applications installed on the CF Card, and it was labeled /Storage Card.  When you try to access the application, but the system has changed the name to /Storage Card1, you'll suffer through some application shortcut target editing when it cannot find the app in question. 

I have seen this posted in many groups and on many boards, and I myself have experienced the problem 3 different times.  It's not fun, nor productive.  This would be my major complaint with the product.   However who is to blame?  HP, Microsoft or IBM?  Highly I doubt this is IBM's fault, but you have to consider it a compatibility issue anyway.

Big Ballah Baby Bean Rating:   user_ratings_4.gif (186 bytes) (4 out of a possible 5 Beans)

Review from www.simplyHPC.com